Skip to main content

Table 1 Comparison of clinical data

From: Conditioning with rabbit versus horse ATG dramatically alters clinical outcomes in identical twins with severe aplastic anemia transplanted with the same allogeneic donor

Clinical data

Twin #1

Twin #2

Disease progression

  Age of presentation

2

2

  Age at transplantation (years)

9

11

  Sex

Female

Female

  Diagnosis

Constitutional SAA with trisomy 8

Constitutional SAA with trisomy 8

  Karyotype at transplant

Trisomy 8

Trisomy 8

Pre-transplantation characteristics

  Absolute neutrophil count (k/μl)

417

996

  Absolute reticulocyte count(k/μl)

61

71.2

  Platelets (k/μl)

16

15

  Time from diagnose to PBSC (years)

7 years

9 years

  Recipient blood type

AB+

AB+

  Donor relationship

Brother

Brother

  Donor blood type

A+

A+

  Donor sex

Male

Male

  HLA match

9 out of 10

9 out of 10

RIC allogeneic PBSC

  Age at transplant

9

11

  Recipient blood type

AB+

AB+

  CD34+ cell dose (×106/kg)

6.24 × 10.6

6.32 × 10.6

  CD3+ cell dose (×107/kg)

42.3 × 10.7

35.2 × 10.7

  Day of 100 % donor T cell chimerism

Day +352

Day +30

  Received DLI and stem cell boost

Yes

No

  Prophylaxis against GVHD

MTX 5 mg/m2 day +1, +3, +6

MTX 5 mg/m2 day +1,+3, +6

 

Cyclosporine

Cyclosporine

Conditioning regimen comparison

  Cyclophosphamide 60 mg/kg IV × 2

Yes

Yes

  Fludarabine 25 mg/m2 IVBP × 5

Yes

Yes

  Rabbit ATG 3.5 mg/kg IV × 4

Yes

No

  Horse ATG 40 mg/kg IV × 4

No

Yes

GVHD prophylaxis

  MTX 5 mg/m2 × 3

Yes

Yes

  Cyclosporine

Yes

Yes

Post-transplantation GVHD

  Time from HSCT to GVHD (months)

20 months

<1 month

  Acute GVHD

No

Yes (grade II GI tract)

  Site of cGVHD

Skin, mouth

Skin, ocular, and lung

  cGVHD grade (severity)

Limited

Extensive

  cGVHD treatment

Daclizumab, cyclosporine

Cyclosporine, sirolimus, MMF, steroid

  

Daclizumab, rituximab, tacrolimus