Skip to main content

Table 3 Comparison of different algorithms in lung cancer immunotherapy prediction

From: The artificial intelligence and machine learning in lung cancer immunotherapy

Model

Algorithm

Category

Strengths

Weaknesses

Example

DenseNet

CNN

Radiomics for TMB and survive prediction

Available for better performance with fewer parameters and computational costs by dense connection and feature reuse

Worse performance than other algorithms under the same video memory usage

[5]

SResCNN

CNN

Radiomics for PD-L1 and survive prediction

Alleviate the network degradation problem caused by layer deepening and increased the generalization ability of the network

Network layer redundancy

Insufficient effective depth

[14]

RF

ML

Radiomics for PD-L1 and survive prediction

Less likely to overfit

Suitable for uneven data sets with missing variables

Easier to explain

Higher accuracy

The larger the number of decision trees, the higher memory usage. Not suitable for situations with high real-time requirements

[22]

Lunit SCOPE IO

DNN

Pathology images for TIL and prognosis prediction

Extracting richer data features and larger capacity

Training process is difficult: gradient explosion, gradient disappearance, etc.

[43]

LCI-RPV

LR

Multi-omics for PD-L1 and Pneumonia prediction

Suitable for linear variables

Easier to explain

Difficult to process nonlinear data or polynomial regression with correlation between data features

[20]

MLP

ANN

Gut microbiome for survive prediction

Suitable for nonlinear model and real-time learning process

Stronger elf-learning function

Slower training rate

Difficult to determine the parameters

[52]

SVM

ML

Combined biomarkers for efficiency prediction

Suitable for high-dimensional space

High accuracy

Not suffer multicollinearity

Flexible selection of kernels for nonlinear correlation

Inefficient to train

Not suitable for plenty training examples

[46]

  1. DenseNet Densely Connected Convolutional Network, SResCNN Small Residual Product Network, CNN Convolutional Neural Network, TMB Tumor Mutation Burden, PD-L1 Programmed Death Ligand 1, RF Random Forests, ML Machine Learning, DNN Deep Neural Networks, ANN Artificial Neural Network, MLP Multilayer Perceptron, SVM support vector machine